Mr Pizza Slice in Red Bank

Worst lunch i have had in a long time. Bread was stale, hot dog was old and cold, fries were crap and just did not live up to reputation. Change the name to Mr. Disappointment. Long history of great food and I don't know what happened but this place has made a complete turn for the worse. Save your money and eat a napkin with ketchup, same effect.

This is a great local place to get a slice of pizza or a some cut potato fries, not super big so if there's a crowd it could be a to go meal but sometimes a small place is nice.

Good service, even better pizza.

Have eaten here many many times as the "old" Mr. Pizza Slice, and several times as the "new" Mr. Pizza Slice. I used to work right across the street. Still love the original pizza, still love the fries, and the "new" Mr. Pizza Slice chicken barbeque bacon ranch pizza is killer. My only complaint is they changed the bread on the Italian hot dog. It used to be on a sub type roll, and they use what they call pizza bread, which we did not like at all for that item. Ordering an original pizza for dinner tonight!

Not sure why but I love this place.

A great slice of pizza

NY style , hole in the wall type of pizza joint. Price is average. Food is good here. I'm not a pizza snob, so I don't know what constitutes good pizza in that regard, but it is perfectly fine to me. The fries are to die for ! Like thick cut potato chips. Perfect little fried disks. Soda machine is "free style" which our family loves. I was slightly disappointed that all of the tables were dirty even though They were not busy at the time. 2 employees watched us clean off our table as they were folding pizza boxes. And there were 3 additional employees up front at the counter. One was clearly the owner or manager, the other was cooking, and one was openly on his cell phone while we were ordering. Thankfully, our Order was taken right away and the food came out in the expected amount of time.Really, it's not my business, but I can't help but get frustrated when I see that kind of aloofness in a small business.

Great pizza,s little pricey.

The food was delicious and great loved!

Holy macaroni this is good pizza. I'm eating a plain slice with a huge smile on. I just got grease on my pants and I don't even care.I'm in heaven for real.

Ellios pizza is better.

ALWAYS delicious food, speedy delivery and great service. Highly recommend them!!

Sal the new Pizza man is such a nice man awesome to finally see a nice Italian Pizza man working !

Fries and cheese were the Best !!

Very cozy spot with that old school pizzeria vibe to it. The staff were very friendly and helpful with my group that showed up. Seats are a bit small, but we fit 4 to a booth just fine. pizza is very well prepared in a traditional style of slice, and the options for sides are great. My friends and I had a good time sitting around, eating and enjoying the spot.

One of my favorite places for a slice in Red Bank!

Cute little place, pizza was fresh and had a nice crunch.

Great food, but very small restaurant

Awful! Under cooked fries over priced and they didn't give me an original pie and charged me more than it was supposed to be and that too was under done. My mother went there in her wedding dress eons ago, going to Mr. Pizza slice was part my child hood, and now it's disgrace to the name. Spent 60$ on feeding my dog who wouldn't even eat the pizza. F#¢k the new owners serving straight garbage!

Ok pizza nothing special

Good place to get a slice

Kinda small but the food and staff are great!

Employees are hard working and polite

The pizza was ok if that but honestly at 2.50 for a plain slice which was fairly small seems like a bit of a rip off to me. I will not be recommending this place to anyone I know. There is far better pizza out there for a lot cheaper.

Awesome thin crust pizza, six slices to a pie perfect for two or three people. Friendly staff and great prices. Lots of local character.

Great little place to eat in Red Bank. Nothing that will blow you away, but I've always left satisfied. The staff are also very welcoming.

Great selection of unusual pizza toppings, love the 40+ Pepsi machine, and especially love playing Ms. Pac Man!

Good pizza and nice guys working here. But really expensive (per slice). I was charged $4.50 for a slice and a cup for water.

Sadly, the pizza isn't as good as before(sauce is kinda watery), however, the fries smack, I will go there exclusively for some round fries

Great pizza and friendly staff

Good friesn

Not as good since ownership changed, but still pretty good. Slices, pies and sandwiches.

I bought a mushroom slice of pizza and a Philly cheese steak. I honestly was impressed and thought to myself I I would definitely go there again. Simply good food.

Mr Pizza Slice killed my father with his Italian hot dog. But the Thin crust was decent. Never going to return, and Mr Pizza Slice will no longer gain my hard earned money.

The most delicious plain slice in the area. It’s so hard to find good plain pizza but this place has it down.

Pizza is pretty good, though nothing special. People working were very nice. Prices are quite reasonable.

Damn this place still has it! Great pizza by the slice. Great variety

I was in the area so I gave them a try. I liked the decor ( old photos, signs, even an original miss pac man machine in working order) very cool. I ordered 2 Sicilian slices and a Gatorade. Pretty good, there meatball or chicken parmigiana I here ( from friends) is very good I will have to stop by have one in the future.

Excellent pizza. Crust is thin and perfect! This place never disappoints. Friendly delivery people. Friendly staff. Best pizza in NJ

I don’t understand how this place could have bad reviews. The pizza is delicious! Hands down the best in town, maybe besides Earth Pizza. The slices are a decent size. I love this place.

The best.

Was not impressed with the quality of the sandwich or the pizza.

Had a couple slices of pizza here, which was ok. Soda machine was out of ice, but they offered to just let me grab a bottle from the fridge. Thanks!

Awesome staff, very friendly and this prime rib pizza is amazing!

Good pizza nothing special. Live 5 mins away and took 2 hours to arrive. The place was better when glen was there.

OVER-CHARGE EVERY TIME...Out of principle I will NEVER go again. I've been there 3x's and every single time they over-charged me for a regular slice, with a different excuse every time, ranging from, "thought you ordered the Sicilian" to "the large slice is more $$ than the small", to "The Original is not on the menu anymore and we charge the same for regular as Sicilian". Whoever heard of large and small slices at a pizza joint, or the regular costing as much as Sicilian?!?Not like they old joint..The manager told me to "Fu#$% off"....they are crooks and while the pizza was good the first two times, today it tasted like they dumped a bucket of salt on it!....guess they left a salty taste in my mouth literally and figuratively. Also, they owners also own Whipped and Gaetano's, so I will be removing those off my list as places I will go.

The pizza was good... A little too greasy though. I like the old fashioned feel to the place!

Love this pizza place! Their garlic parmesan wings are amazing!!!!

Food here is the best in Red Bank! everyone who works there makes u feel like family!

Best pizza ever.